
Review
The Lie Collector
A Novel of Manhattan
by Ann Howard Creel
Black Rose Writing. 01-28-2027. Ebook. 291 pp. $5.99
In a city where secrets run rampant and trust is a risk, how do you uncover the truth?
A fictional exploration of Oak Ridge, Tennessee, a significant site of the World War II Manhattan Project, Creel’s (The Magic of Ordinary Days) first-person narrative steers a young woman accustomed to the quiet, reliable rhythms of farm life into an industrious, high-security city where “friendships are a liability.”
It’s 1944 in Sweetwater, Tennessee and Lucy Mercer, 25, is content with life on her family’s farm and optimistic about a future with her fiancé, Greg. Before they settle down, Greg is compelled to contribute his part to the war and go to work in the military town, Oak Ridge. Lucy scarcely hears from Greg after he enters the restricted city, which is shrouded in secrets, and then he vanishes completely. Officials there offer few answers about Greg’s disappearance, so a desperate Lucy infiltrates the city by working under the guise of a chauffeurette. The dominant rule in Oak Ridge is not to ask questions, a rule that Lucy continually breaks; who can she trust with a growing battery of lies, her own and those she uncovers inside its fences?
Lucy firmly describes herself as rebellious, though she grows into that claim gradually. It’s late in the book when she at last proves this quality through credibly defiant actions. Readers are rewarded with Lucy’s discoveries as she develops inner-strength and a new view of the world.
Nods to 1940s fashion trends, such as Victory Roll hairstyles, half-moon glasses, and bold red lipstick help Creel set the scene for an immersive story. At times, the pacing is uneven, particularly at the beginning and end of the novel: a swift introduction plunges a still-developing protagonist into a seemingly insurmountable obstacle, which will leave readers breathless or intrigued. The middle of the book is ideally paced; Lucy cautiously follows leads and rebounds from misjudgment and red herrings, gradually navigating toward the climax. By the resolution, every question has been neatly answered. Throughout the tale, Lucy’s narration occasionally spells out what readers could happily infer on their own.
An author’s note demonstrates thorough historical research and consultation of oral histories. This cross-genre novel has high potential as a book club choice; it’s a page-turner for avid thriller and historical fiction readers.
It’s 1944 in Sweetwater, Tennessee and Lucy Mercer, 25, is content with life on her family’s farm and optimistic about a future with her fiancé, Greg. Before they settle down, Greg is compelled to contribute his part to the war and go to work in the military town, Oak Ridge. Lucy scarcely hears from Greg after he enters the restricted city, which is shrouded in secrets, and then he vanishes completely. Officials there offer few answers about Greg’s disappearance, so a desperate Lucy infiltrates the city by working under the guise of a chauffeurette. The dominant rule in Oak Ridge is not to ask questions, a rule that Lucy continually breaks; who can she trust with a growing battery of lies, her own and those she uncovers inside its fences?
Lucy firmly describes herself as rebellious, though she grows into that claim gradually. It’s late in the book when she at last proves this quality through credibly defiant actions. Readers are rewarded with Lucy’s discoveries as she develops inner-strength and a new view of the world.
Nods to 1940s fashion trends, such as Victory Roll hairstyles, half-moon glasses, and bold red lipstick help Creel set the scene for an immersive story. At times, the pacing is uneven, particularly at the beginning and end of the novel: a swift introduction plunges a still-developing protagonist into a seemingly insurmountable obstacle, which will leave readers breathless or intrigued. The middle of the book is ideally paced; Lucy cautiously follows leads and rebounds from misjudgment and red herrings, gradually navigating toward the climax. By the resolution, every question has been neatly answered. Throughout the tale, Lucy’s narration occasionally spells out what readers could happily infer on their own.
An author’s note demonstrates thorough historical research and consultation of oral histories. This cross-genre novel has high potential as a book club choice; it’s a page-turner for avid thriller and historical fiction readers.
Reader & Market Readiness Ratings
- Reader Appeal★★★★☆
- Shelf Readiness★★★★☆
- Professional Polish★★★★☆
- Audience Fit★★★★★
- Discovery Potential★★★★☆
- Review-ready Language★★★★☆
- Book-club Potential★★★★★
Book Details
- Author
- Ann Howard Creel
- Format
- Ebook
- Pages
- 291
- Publisher
- Black Rose Writing
- List price
- $5.99
- Category
- Fiction
- KeywordsAuthor-provided
- Oak Ridge, Manhattan Project, World War II, love story, historical fiction
- Publication date
- 01-28-2027
- Language
- English
- Genres
- Action/Adventure Historical, Romance Historical
